Nothing’s changed with VAR, says Gareth Southgate

By Sports Desk October 05, 2023

England boss Gareth Southgate believes VAR has not done anything to resolve controversial refereeing decisions.

The off-field decision-making process has come under renewed fire this week after Liverpool were denied a fair goal in their defeat at Tottenham when VAR Darren England mistakenly thought the on-field decision was onside and inadvertently validated the linesman’s offside call, with play restarting before the mistake was noticed.

There has been a huge fallout from the gaffe, with Reds boss Jurgen Klopp calling for the game to be replayed while the Professional Game Match Officials Limited (PGMOL) has announced a review into VAR and its practices.

Southgate has always been against it and says nothing has changed from when on-field decisions were final.

“Well, all I would say is everybody used to go to the pub and moan about the ref and they still go to the pub and moan about the ref,” he quipped.

“So I’m not sure what we’ve resolved, really. I don’t like it, never have, so I have sort of dismissed it.

“I just was always brought up as a kid that the referee’s decision was final. You might agree or disagree but we have to get on with it.

“I didn’t ever feel we were going to resolve every issue.

“I think we are probably too far down the line now to go back but I didn’t like it from the off.

“Once you open up a technology opportunity, you are normally going that way and you have got to refine and improve on what happens. But yes, I don’t like it.”

The PGMOL has taken unprecedented steps in recent times of retrospectively releasing audio of the decision-making process, including England’s expletive-filled mistake at the weekend.

But fans in the stadium remain in the dark at the time, often left waiting for up to five minutes while decisions are scrutinised in Stockley Park.

“When I am at games I am always conscious that the only people who don’t know what is going on are the people who have paid to go,” he said. “I find that really difficult.

“I am sitting in the stadium next to people and I am lucky as I normally get a free ticket and other people pay a lot of money and haven’t got a clue or are on the phone to someone at home asking what’s going on.

“The frustration, you can feel it in the stadium, you can feel the view.

“I know if we didn’t have it people would go back to, ‘well this could be resolved’, but when I am in the stadiums my sense is they don’t necessarily want 14 minutes of added time or a decision by something that they are not totally across the process of.”

Related items

  • Martino resigns as Inter Miami coach after early playoff exit Martino resigns as Inter Miami coach after early playoff exit

    Gerardo Martino has resigned as Inter Miami's head coach due to personal reasons, the MLS side have confirmed.

    The Argentine ends his 17-month stint in charge of the Herons following their MLS Cup exit just under a fortnight ago.

    Martino, who oversaw Miami's Leagues Cup triumph soon after his arrival last season, guided the franchise to this year's Supporters' Shield with a regular-season record tally of 74 points.

    However, they were eliminated by his former side Atlanta United in round one of the MLS Cup playoffs.

    Miami opened their best-of-three series against Atlanta with a 2-1 win, only to lose by the same scoreline in Game 2 before falling to a dramatic 3-2 defeat in the decider.

    “It has been an honour to work at such a special club, and to lead such a special team," Martino said.  

    "I’ve enjoyed my stay at Inter Miami and will treasure the memories made and relationships forged here for the rest of my life.

    "I depart with nothing but gratitude for my time here and would like to offer sincere thanks to everyone that made it possible."

  • Fonseca: Milan have 'respect' but 'are not afraid' of Juventus Fonseca: Milan have 'respect' but 'are not afraid' of Juventus

    Paulo Fonseca said Milan have plenty of "respect" for Juventus, but his side "are not afraid" of their rivals ahead of their Serie A clash on Saturday. 

    After a slow start to the season, Milan are six points adrift of Juventus in the table, but only a place behind them, as they aim to make up the ground on the top six. 

    The Rossoneri have played a game less than Thiago Motta's side, and could catapult themselves back into the Scudetto picture with a win this weekend. 

    Milan return to the San Siro for the first time since a 2-0 defeat to Napoli at the end of October, and could register two consecutive home defeats in Serie A for the first time since between October and November in 2023. 

    "It is not decisive, but it is important, like all of them," Fonseca told reporters ahead of Saturday's game.

    "I can't say that the game against Juve is more important than the next one against Empoli because we need consecutive victories.

    "It's a different game, but I always think positively. We are Milan, we have a lot of respect for the 'Bianconeri', but we are not afraid. We are here ready to win."

    A boost for Milan is that Juventus will be without top scorer Dusan Vlahovic for Saturday's clash after returning from international duty with a muscle problem. 

    Despite the Serbian's absence, Fonseca was aware of the danger his probable replacement, Timothy Weah, would pose, having managed him during his time at Lille. 

    "Juve knows how to adapt very well. I don't know if Weah will play," Fonseca said.

    "Weah is very fast and attacks deep, not like Vlahovic. It will not be the same thing of course.

    "We will have to pay attention to movements in depth and less to support work, because he is a player who does less of this job."

    While Fonseca has endured a stuttering start to his tenure at the San Siro, Milan have shown they have the ability to match the very best. 

    They beat rivals Inter in October before stunning Real Madrid at the Bernabeu in their last Champions League encounter, keeping their play-off hopes alive. 

    "I believe it's a matter of motivation and not pressure," Fonseca said.

    "Against Inter, Juve and Real it is easy to be motivated, it's more difficult to go to Cagliari and have the same motivation.

    "Pressure is always with us, every day. If we don't want to have pressure, then we shouldn't be here."

  • 'Right guy at the right time' - Amorim confident of changing Man Utd's fortunes 'Right guy at the right time' - Amorim confident of changing Man Utd's fortunes

    Ruben Amorim believes he is the "right guy at the right time" to turn Manchester United's fortunes around.

    The 39-year-old signed a two-and-a-half-year deal earlier this month to keep him at Old Trafford until June 2027, replacing Erik ten Hag after he was sacked in October.

    Amorim is the sixth permanent United manager since Alex Ferguson retired in 2013, having left Sporting CP to take charge during the international break.

    He won two Primeira Liga titles as Sporting head coach as well as two Taca da Liga trophies, while he led the club to a perfect start in the league this season, winning all 11 of their games.

    United sit 13th in the Premier League table ahead of their trip to Ipswich Town on 15 points, though they are just four points behind Chelsea in third.

    Amorim recognised the size of the task ahead of him in Manchester but is confident he can make a change.

    "I'm a little bit of a dreamer and I believe in myself, and I believe in the club," he said during his first press conference.

    "I think we have the same idea, the same mindset and that can help.

    "I truly believe in the players; I know you don't believe a lot, but I do. I want to try new things. You guys don't think it's possible, I do.

    "Call me naive, but I believe I am the right guy at the right time. I truly believe I am the right guy."

    Aged 39 years and 302 days, Amorim will be the youngest to take charge of his first match for the Red Devils since Wilf McGuinness in August 1969 (31y 288d).

    United have won just four of their 11 league games so far this season, and have struggled in front of goal, netting just 12 times so far.

    Expected to implement his favoured 3-4-3 formation, Amorim admitted it would take time for the club to adapt and has asked for patience as the players get used to his tactics.

    "I know at Manchester United we have to win games. We need a lot of time because it's a tough league, we have to improve a lot to try to win the title," he added.

    "We have to change the physical aspect of the team. I don't know how long it will take."

© 2024 SportsMaxTV All Rights Reserved.