Unconvinced about the buying of student-athletes in Jamaica

By Melissa Talbert June 29, 2020

With COVID-19 keeping children all over the island at home this term, I began to make a link between them and student-athletes who, because of the changing nature of sports, move from school to school, resulting in a similar sort of dislocation.

Working from home for the student is an adjustment. All of a sudden greater levels of discipline are required if they are to do well since they do not have the same level of supervision.

This is also true for the athlete who moves from one school to another. That athlete has come to increase the school’s chances at success in whatever field of endeavour but he or she is a stranger. The checks and balances that take place with a student the school knows may not be there.

Then, of course, there is the obvious displacement, trying to acquire new friends, trying to fit into a different culture, getting to understand what is required of you from teachers. It can all be too much, and while the athlete may continue to do well on the field, other areas of their lives suffer.

COVID-19 has also impacted the schools significantly. Without the community, one school is as good as another, but the resources of the school also impact the school’s performances.

Schools with ready access to technology like WiFi, tablets and PCs will have an advantage, just like those schools with more resources in their sports departments.

That is attractive on the face of it and many students will leave their institutions to go to where those resources are.

But here’s the problem. The biggest resources are the students themselves. The same is true of the athlete. So when the brain drain takes place because of this COVID-19, or the athlete drain because of champs, Manning or daCosta Cup, the school that was struggling, struggles even more.

Now how can a school attract investment if all their potential stars leave? How will they attract other students, if they have no legacy of producing stars in whatever field?

That school is doomed to remain an institution that produces mediocrity for the most part.

In an interview with Caribbean Intelligence, Dr Lascelve Graham, a former coach of the St George’s football team said,  “...everybody has a right to education and you don’t have more of a right to education if you are a sports star.”

What is the solution?

The solution is to get school administration, coaches, teachers and parents to see the beauty in spending the time to cultivate greatness where it is first planted.

But instead, what is happening now, are mass migrations from ‘no-name schools’, to the traditional sporting powerhouses. What is happening now, are that many student-athletes are getting lost along the way, forced to compete for spaces at the front of a long line at these traditional schools. To what end?

Please share your thoughts on Twitter (@SportsMax_Carib) or in the comments section on Facebook (@SportsMax). Don’t forget to use #IAmNotAFan. Until next time!

Related items

  • Michael Holding’s look at institutional racism important to Caribbean views on class Michael Holding’s look at institutional racism important to Caribbean views on class

    Fast-bowling legend-turned-legendary commentator, Michael Holding, effortlessly threw case studies here and there while backing up his views on the issue of racism.

  • Zidane hails 'phenomenal' Courtois after another clean sheet Zidane hails 'phenomenal' Courtois after another clean sheet

    Zinedine Zidane praised the "phenomenal" Thibaut Courtois after Real Madrid took another step towards the LaLiga title with a win over Deportivo Alaves.

    Madrid kept a clean sheet for the fifth straight game, recording a 2-0 win on Friday to move four points clear of rivals Barcelona with three games remaining.

    Zidane lauded Courtois, who made four saves in Madrid's win as Karim Benzema netted a penalty before Marco Asensio's second-half goal.

    "He has a very big influence. He is our goalkeeper, what he is doing every game is phenomenal," Madrid coach Zidane told a news conference, via AS.

    "It is a matter for everyone when it comes to defending … today, he [Courtois] has been good for us with two or three stops, and then the strength of the entire team.

    "We have to continue like this."

    Madrid scored a penalty for the third straight game, while the VAR was needed to award Asensio's goal after it was initially ruled out due to an offside decision against Benzema.

    As another clean sheet helped Madrid, Zidane said he was happy with his team, who are away to Granada on Monday.

    "I'm not worried because the important thing is to win matches," he said.

    "We didn't score four or five goals, but because there is an opponent who defends. We scored two goals, one very beautiful in play.

    "I am happy and calm with what we are doing."

  • Varane dismisses VAR talk as Real Madrid close in on LaLiga title Varane dismisses VAR talk as Real Madrid close in on LaLiga title

    Raphael Varane dismissed talk the VAR favoured Real Madrid after the LaLiga giants moved closer to the league title with a win over Deportivo Alaves.

    A Karim Benzema penalty and Marco Asensio goal saw Madrid record a 2-0 win on Friday, moving four points clear of rivals Barcelona with three games left.

    Madrid were awarded a spot-kick for the third straight game, while the VAR was needed after Asensio's goal was initially incorrectly ruled out for an offside decision against Benzema.

    Varane, who helped Madrid keep a clean sheet for the fifth straight game, was unfazed by any talk decisions were going his team's way.

    "Outside noise doesn't matter to us. We are focused on winning and giving everything on the pitch," the defender told Movistar.

    "We don't control the VAR, we control the effort and attitude we show on the pitch."

    Madrid are closing in on their first league title since 2016-17, with Barcelona having clinched the past two crowns.

    Varane said Madrid still had finals to play ahead of matches against Granada, Villarreal and Leganes to finish the league season.

    "We are focused on our objective and we have three finals left," he said.

    "It was important to win, of course, but it is very important to keep a clean sheet. That gives us a lot of confidence.

    "We will continue with the positive dynamics we have."

© 2020 SportsMaxTV All Rights Reserved.