Can power and transparency co-exist? – Maybe not in the TTFA

By Mariah Ramharack June 14, 2020
#INCASEYOUMISSEDIT with Mariah Ramharack #INCASEYOUMISSEDIT with Mariah Ramharack

Power is the ability to direct or influence the behaviour of others or the course of events. Transparency in governance focuses on honesty and openness. Question; is it that when one gets power it clouds their ability to be transparent? 

If power doesn’t cloud the ability to be transparent, then has the Trinidad and Tobago Football Association (TTFA) been creating a culture where the two are diametrically opposed?

Recently, based on the way events have unfolded within the TTFA, I am led to believe that power clouds transparency.

On Sunday, November 24th 2019, then President of the Secondary Schools Football League (SSFL), William Wallace defeated incumbent David John-Williams to become the new TTFA boss, at the Home of Football in Couva. It took two rounds of voting, but in the end, Wallace received 26 votes to John-Williams’ 20.

The election result marked the end of a stormy tenure for John-Williams, who was often accused by his detractors of leading an authoritarian administration that lacked transparency.

Upon becoming TTFA President, Wallace gave the SportsMax Zone his word to keep in contact and ensure that the public was updated on the affairs of the TTFA.

According to him, this was of utmost importance because he did not want to lead in the manner for which he turned ouster of John-Williams.

But then, every good story has a twist.

On March 17th, a mere four months after Wallace occupies office, FIFA appoints a normalization committee to run the TTFA. Questions were immediately raised. Was FIFA being unfair? Even I felt there was not enough time given to the newly elected administration to prove themselves.

Recently I’ve had to rethink my position with the surfacing of two contracts signed by the Wallace administration. The two contracts have provoked numerous questions. Questions that are yet to be answered.

The first discrepancy is with the contract afforded to T&T’s Men’s National Senior Team Head Coach Terry Fenwick by the TTFA.

Based on the findings of a SportsMax Zone investigation, the contract Fenwick signed was not the one agreed upon by the Board members. The same Wallace, who described the former head of the administration of being a dictator, went ahead with a contract that was not agreed upon by the board. Is this a case of power clouding transparency?

After constant requests from the SportsMax Zone for Wallace to clear the air, he eventually came to the forefront explaining it was simply an “error”. An error that is a legally binding document for the TTFA five months later?

A debt-riddled organization making errors where money is concerned?

Would the error have been rectified if it was not exposed?

Wallace’s reason for the additional sum added to the contract is that Fenwick sourced private sponsorship. Why include a private sponsor in an official TTFA contract? What if the sponsor falls through? And who is this sponsor? What are they getting from Fenwick or the TTFA in return?

TT Pro League Board representative Brent Sancho provided this comment on the matter, “Football has been in the doldrums for the last 20/25 years. Corruption, lack of transparency, governance issues, and greed has been the order of the day and this latest instalment by the Wallace regime is a continuation of this disease that has infected the growth of the sport. These men have put yet another nail in the coffin of our aspiring young footballers.”

Wallace has said the clerical error is being rectified, meaning Fenwick’s salary will not be affected. But there are losers with this latest faux pas taking centre stage. Football will lose. The sport suffers, the footballers suffer and the reputation of Trinidad and Tobago suffers.

Then, as if one error wasn’t enough, the Avec Sport contract surfaces and again the views of the board seem to have been disregarded.

The terms of the contract, worth approximately TT$25 million, are that the TTFA will receive a “Gifted Pro Kit Allowance” from Avec but are to buy a minimum of 7500 replica shirts in each contract year for four years.

According to the terms of the contract, the TTFA’s sponsors will spend half a million pounds with Avec Sport. If this figure isn’t met over the course of the four years, the TTFA will pay for all the kits provided over the period. This deal is also alleged not to have had the backing or approval of the board.

This information about the manner in which the TTFA is conducting business forces me to re-think my feelings on the issue of FIFA’s normalization committee running the affairs of the TTFA. I am led to believe that power has a way of clouding transparency and if not, it definitely has a history of doing so at the TTFA.

Related items

  • Solskjaer hints returning Smalling could have Man Utd future Solskjaer hints returning Smalling could have Man Utd future

    Ole Gunnar Solskjaer has hinted Chris Smalling could have a Manchester United future after he completed an impressive loan spell with Roma.

    Defender Smalling on Tuesday stated he was "gutted" that he would play no further part in Roma's quest to win the Europa League.

    The centre-back was rock solid at the heart of the Eternal City giants' defence during his season in Italy, but the loan agreement ended after Roma's final Serie A match of the campaign against Juventus on Saturday.

    He tweeted following his Roma departure: "I'm gutted that I can't finish what we started this season.

    "To experience the love shown to me in such a short time was extra special and it will not be forgotten. I want to thank and wish all the players and staff the best of luck against Sevilla. DAJE ROMA!"

    Solskjaer suggested the former Fulham man may play a part at Old Trafford next season.

    "I think Chris has shown over his career how valuable he is at Manchester United," Solskjaer said ahead of United's Europa League last-16 second-leg tie against LASK on Wednesday.

    "This season was about him being regular and going to Roma and showing how good a centre-back he is.

    "I wanted to give Harry [Maguire], Vic [Lindelof] and maybe Axel [Tuanzebe] a chance.

    "It was best for him to go and play for a year in Roma and he has shown he will be valuable. I've been speaking to Chris throughout and I've been delighted with his season."

    Smalling played in 30 of Roma's Serie A matches as they finished fifth, while he also made five starts in the Europa League.

  • Brandon Williams signs long-term Man Utd deal Brandon Williams signs long-term Man Utd deal

    Brandon Williams has signed a contract extension at Manchester United running until June 2024, with an option for another year.

    The England Under-20 full-back has enjoyed a breakthrough campaign at Old Trafford this season, making 33 appearances in all competitions.

    United resume their Europa League campaign against LASK on Wednesday, with an ankle injury to Luke Shaw meaning Williams could be key to Ole Gunnar Solskjaer's team's hopes of success.

    "Signing this contract is another really proud moment for myself and my family," the 19-year-old said.

    "Having been at Manchester United since I was seven years old, it's genuinely a dream come true to be playing in the first team.

    "It has taken a huge amount of hard work to reach this point and it has been really special for me to break through into the squad.

    "I've learned a lot throughout the season from the manager, his coaching staff and my team-mates and I want to repay the trust that they have all shown in me.

    "I know that everyone at the club is working really hard every day to achieve success in the coming years and I am really excited to be a part of that."

    United boss Solskjaer believes Williams' time coming through the ranks has given him an invaluable affinity with the club.

    "Brandon has had an excellent first season, so we are delighted that he has signed a new contract," he said of the youngster, who scored his maiden Premier League goal in a dramatic 3-3 draw at Sheffield United.

    "This new deal is a real testament to his hard work and the progress that he has made since his debut. Brandon never looked back after stepping up from the academy and, having come all the way through the system, he understands what it means to play for Manchester United.

    "He has all of the attributes required to be a member of this exciting young squad. He will continue to learn every day in training and we look forward to watching him develop over the coming seasons."

    United will face a Europa League quarter-final against either Istanbul Basaksehir or Copenhagen, barring the unlikely scenario of LASK overturning a 5-0 first-leg deficit at Old Trafford.

  • Florentino Perez honours Iker Casillas: He has conquered the hearts of the Madridistas Florentino Perez honours Iker Casillas: He has conquered the hearts of the Madridistas

    Iker Casillas "conquered the hearts of the Madridistas" and Real Madrid will always be his home, said president Florentino Perez in a glowing tribute.

    Los Blancos legend Casillas officially announced his retirement on Tuesday, although he has not played since suffering a heart attack in training with Porto on May 1 last year.

    Casillas rose through the youth ranks at the Santiago Bernabeu, making his first-team debut in 1999 as a teenager and going on to make 725 appearances for the club before departing in 2015.

    During that time, former captain Casillas won every major honour possible with Madrid – including five LaLiga titles and the Champions League on three occasions, while he also became a two-time European Champion and a World Cup winner with Spain.

    Perez said Casillas earned the respect of team-mates and rivals alike during a glittering career.

    "Iker Casillas is one of the great symbols of Real Madrid. The Madridistas are especially proud of one of our eternal captains today, captain also of the Spanish national team," Perez said. 

    "Today, Iker Casillas bids farewell as a professional player, having contributed to further enlarging the myth and Real Madrid legend.

    "He came to our club as a boy, at just nine years old, and here he has grown up, he has formed and has become a benchmark for all football fans.

    "From Real Madrid today we want to convey to you our love, our admiration, and of course, our gratitude for all that he has given us, both inside and outside the pitches. 

    "And I also want to thank your wife Sara, all the support she's always given to Iker Casillas. For Sara, also, all our affection.

    "Iker represents the values of Real Madrid. This club is the most beloved and admired in the world and is admired [for] players like Iker Casillas. With his commitment, with his work and with his humility he has conquered the hearts of the Madridistas, but also the respect of their rivals.

    "In this club, with this shield and this jersey, he's won it all. For Real Madrid and for Madridistas from all corners of the world it has been an honour to have a goalkeeper, a captain, like Iker Casillas.

    "He is a reference for children who come to our Real Madrid City with the dream to one day wear our jersey. His legacy will always be here. Iker knows that this is and will always be your home."

© 2020 SportsMaxTV All Rights Reserved.