Tom Brady: What happened to the six QBs drafted before Patriots legend?

By Sports Desk April 16, 2020

The 2000 NFL Draft will be remembered as arguably the most momentous in league history.

All the excitement that comes with the first round had long since dissipated by the time the New England Patriots selected in the sixth round with pick 199.

They used that choice on a skinny quarterback from the University of Michigan by the name of Tom Brady.

Brady was the seventh quarterback off the board, a fact few gave much thought to at the time. Twenty years and six Super Bowl titles for Brady and the Patriots later, and the question of just how six quarterbacks went before him is one of the great NFL mysteries.

Who were those six quarterbacks? And how did they fare in the pros? We took a look back at their careers.


Chad Pennington - Round 1, Pick 18 (New York Jets)

Pennington had the distinction of being the first quarterback off the board but did not have the career the Jets were hoping when they selected him out of Marshall.

He did have his highs. Pennington led the NFL in passer rating in 2002 as the Jets pipped the Patriots to the AFC East title. He was Comeback Player of the Year in 2006 after leading the Jets to the playoffs following a 2005 campaign derailed by shoulder injuries.

The same award came his way in 2008 when Pennington, having been released by the Jets in the wake of a dismal 2007, guided the Miami Dolphins to AFC East glory with an injured Brady on the sidelines for the Patriots. 

Injuries thwarted his hopes of further success in Miami and he eventually retired in 2012.

Giovanni Carmazzi - Round 3, Pick 65 (San Francisco 49ers)

Instead of going with Brady, the Bay Area boy who idolised the 49ers and Joe Montana, San Francisco selected Carmazzi, who had excelled at college football minnow Hofstra.

It proved a significant misstep, Carmazzi lost to Brady and the Patriots in the exhibition Hall of Fame game prior to the 2000 NFL season and never played a regular-season snap.

Tim Rattay, selected in the same draft in the seventh round, fared better than Carmazzi and stuck around on the Niners' roster. Carmazzi left the 49ers in 2001 and went on to have stints with NFL Europe's Rhein Fire and the BC Lions and Calgary Stampeders of the Canadian Football League.

Chris Redman - Round 3, Pick 75 (Baltimore Ravens)

Though his career was significantly less distinguished than that of Brady, Redman does have a Super Bowl ring.

He appeared in two games and attempted three passes as the Ravens won Super Bowl XXXV in his rookie year.

Redman went 3-3 in six games as a starter for the Ravens in 2002, leaving Baltimore in 2003 and serving briefly as a team-mate of Brady when he joined the Patriots in 2004, although he failed to make the 53-man roster.

A brief stint with the Tennessee Titans followed in 2005 before, having signed with the Austin Wranglers of the Arena League, the Atlanta Falcons came calling in 2007. Redman spent five seasons as backup with the Falcons before he was released in 2012.

Tee Martin - Round 5, Pick 163 (Pittsburgh Steelers)

Martin won a National Championship in college with Tennessee, but never came close to reaching similar heights in the pros.

He failed to make the Steelers' 53-man roster as a rookie and featured in only one game in 2001.

Like Carmazzi, Martin also made the move to NFL Europe with the Rhein Fire and led them to a World Bowl appearance in the 2002 season.

Spells with the Philadelphia Eagles and Oakland Raiders, for whom he appeared in two games, followed, with Martin's pro career coming to an end with the Winnipeg Blue Bombers in the CFL.

Martin went into coaching in 2006 and is now an assistant head coach with Tennessee.

Marc Bulger - Round 6, Pick 168 (New Orleans Saints)

Bulger was released by the Saints after training camp and failed to stick with their division rivals the Atlanta Falcons. However, he was picked up by the St. Louis Rams late in the 2000 season in what proved an astute move.

He helped the Rams go from 0-5 to 7-9 in 2002 with starter Kurt Warner on the sidelines. Bulger then took over for a concussed Warner after Week 1 of 2003 and, following a 12-4 season that ended in defeat in the NFC Divisional Round, never gave the starting job back. 

Bulger twice went to the Pro Bowl and went 41-54 for his career, which ended in 2010 after a one-year spell with the Ravens. A fine career for a sixth-round pick, but a long way from what Brady achieved.

Spergon Wynn - Round 6, Pick 183 (Cleveland Browns)

Given the Browns' well-documented quarterback woes that they hope are now over with Baker Mayfield, it is tantalising to think what might have been had they picked Brady, particularly as they had the first overall selection that year too.

Instead, Cleveland went with Wynn, who played in seven games as a rookie, his sole start a 48-0 loss to the Jacksonville Jaguars.

A trade to the Minnesota Vikings followed a spell in NFL Europe with the Amsterdam Admirals. He went 0-2 in two games with Minnesota before bouncing around the CFL in spells with the BC Lions, Blue Bombers and Toronto Argonauts.

Related items

  • I'm not worried about it - Rams CB Jalen Ramsey tired of contract talk I'm not worried about it - Rams CB Jalen Ramsey tired of contract talk

    Jalen Ramsey has no interest in repeatedly discussing his contract, with the Los Angeles Rams cornerback prepared to leave the matter firmly in his agent's hands.

    A year ago the three-time Pro Bowler turned up at the Jacksonville Jaguars training camp in an armoured money truck, a not-so-subtle nod to his wish to land a big contract.

    That was not forthcoming from the Jags, who instead shipped Ramsey to the Rams for two first-round picks and a fourth-rounder in October.

    His need for a new deal has not gone away, though, as the defensive back is beginning the final season of his five-year rookie contract, and with plenty of leverage given the haul the Rams parted with to land him.

    "I'm worried about what I can worry about," Ramsey told reporters. 

    "I'm controlling what I can control."

    However, as the questions continued, Ramsey grew increasingly frustrated.

    "I answered it. I said my agent and the front office, they gonna handle it," Ramsey added.

    "I'm worried about what I can worry about, I'm controlling what I can control.

    "Either accept the answer or keep it pushing. I don't want to be disrespectful, but that's the answer."

    The 25-year-old then walked out of his Zoom media session during a pause in questions before being convinced to return.

    At that point, he addressed his contract situation in greater depth, revealing he had informed his agent David Mulugheta to only call him when a deal had been reached.

    "I told y'all at the beginning of this, I said I'm controlling what I can control and when you asked me the question about my contract, I said I'm letting my agent, who is by far the best agent in the game, David Mulugheta, and the front office handle it," Ramsey added.

    "I can't do anything about it. I'm not worried about it. I'm trying to do my job as a football player. I'm trying to be a leader on the team, I'm not gonna do every Zoom session or however we gonna do them this year, talking about my contract. Look, if it comes, it comes. It's gonna be a surprise to me like it's gonna be a surprise to y'all.

    "I said, 'I want you to call me one time', I said, 'When my deal is done'. I said, 'When you feel like my deal is done, call me'. That's it'. 

    "I'm not worried about it. I'm worried about football."

  • Lions remove Stafford from reserve/COVID-19 list after false-positive test Lions remove Stafford from reserve/COVID-19 list after false-positive test

    Detroit Lions quarterback Matthew Stafford has been removed from the reserve/COVID-19 list, the NFL team announced on Tuesday.

    The Lions said Stafford returned a false-positive test following two negative coronavirus tests last week, while insisting the 2014 Pro Bowler never contracted COVID-19.

    Stafford was placed on the reserve/COVID-19 list on Saturday.

    "Today we removed Matthew Stafford from the COVID-IR list and onto the Active Roster," the Lions said in a statement.

    "As a result of a False-Positive test result, he was forced due to NFL/NFLPA protocols to sit out until he received two negative tests. His testing sequence for the Pre-Entry period was: negative, negative, False-Positive. The next three tests were all negative. 

    "To be clear, Matthew does NOT have COVID-19 and never has had COVID-19 and the test in question was a False-Positive. Also, all of Matthew's family have been tested and everyone is negative."

    The Lions are scheduled to open their 2020 season against the Chicago Bears on September 13.

  • Broncos star Von Miller considered sitting out NFL season Broncos star Von Miller considered sitting out NFL season

    Denver Broncos star Von Miller said he considered opting out of the 2020 NFL season due to coronavirus concerns.

    Miller – a Super Bowl champion and eight-time Pro Bowler – was among the highest profile American athletes to test positive for COVID-19 in April before being cleared of coronavirus two weeks later.

    However, the Broncos linebacker revealed he thought about sitting out the season, which is scheduled to begin in September.

    "I thought about it,'' the 31-year-old said on Tuesday. " ... I thought about all of my family, I took serious consideration and the things that could possibly happen.

    "It's not a 100 per cent bubble like basketball, so there are always going to be holes, but I felt like the job the Broncos were doing to keep us safe was enough for me not to opt out.''

    Miller, an asthma sufferer, added: "I did [have trouble], it was hard for me to get my wind back, probably for two or three weeks after the virus.

    "During the virus I lost a lot of weight -- everybody is not the same, but for me I lost my taste and smell, I couldn't really, like, eat and when you can't taste or smell you kind of lose your appetite ... It was tough, no doubt about it, it was tough.''

    "I just thought about it, I just really through about all the things that could possibly happen,'' Miller continued. "I thought about this season is different, I thought about -- I weighed the positives and negatives and just came to my own decision that I could play.

    "But I thought about me having asthma ... I feel like every player should do that, I feel like every player should think about everything they could do.''

    The Broncos are set to open their season against the Tennessee Titans on September 14.


© 2020 SportsMaxTV All Rights Reserved.