A thousand days on, Colin Kaepernick's NFL exile still makes no sense

By Sports Desk September 28, 2019

It has never been easier to play the hardest position in professional sport, but 1,000 days on from Colin Kaepernick's last start, NFL teams continue to persist with quarterbacks who make their job look exceedingly difficult.

On January 1, 2017, Kaepernick played what remains his last NFL game as the San Francisco 49ers suffered a narrow 25-23 defeat to the Seattle Seahawks to end the 2016 campaign.

Kaepernick, who took the league by storm in leading the 49ers to a Super Bowl appearance in the 2012 season and then on a run to a third successive NFC Championship game in the subsequent year, had the fifth-highest quarterback rating of any signal-caller to play that week.

Despite performing admirably in 2016 for a 49ers team that featured little of the potential being displayed by the 2019 vintage, Kaepernick - unquestionably one of the most exciting quarterbacks of the modern era - remains unsigned despite regularly indicating his desire to play in the league again.

NFL teams are seemingly still unwilling to offer a contract to a player who stoked such widespread controversy by kneeling during the national anthem to protest against racial injustice and police brutality in that 2016 campaign.

While some may be able to empathise with the reluctance of the owners to risk negative publicity, the reasons frequently provided for Kaepernick not being in the league ring hollow in the face of the resume of a player whose skill set is perfectly suited to the NFL in 2019.

The NFL is blessed with a litany of talented play-callers who rely heavily on the use of play-action, motion, jet sweeps and quarterback rollouts to confound defenses and make things more comfortable for the man passing the football.

That Kaepernick, a quarterback whose playoff success came as a result of his mobility and aptitude for making plays with his arm and his legs, does not have a place in a league that heavily favours facets of the game he excelled in with the Niners flies in the face of the NFL's commitment to adaptability.

Coaches have frequently adapted their schemes to various quarterbacks yet Kaepernick, who seamlessly slotted into Chip Kelly's complex scheme in 2016, could again only watch from home as the New York Jets sent former sixth-round pick Luke Falk to the slaughter against the New England Patriots last week, while the New York Giants made the switch from Eli Manning to Daniel Jones, coincidentally in part because of the latter's superior mobility.

The Giants look to have Manning's heir apparent in first-round rookie Jones, who thrived in a comeback win over the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, but Week 4 of the 2019 season will again see a host of quarterbacks who have done nothing to prove they are superior to Kaepernick suit up across the league.

Mason Rudolph will be backed up by undrafted free agent rookie Devlin Hodges for the Pittsburgh Steelers, who parted with Joshua Dobbs as the Jacksonville Jaguars sent a fifth-round pick to acquire a player who has attempted 12 NFL passes to back up rookie Gardner Minshew.

The Tennessee Titans head into their fourth game of the year with two pillars of mediocrity on the quarterback depth chart in Marcus Mariota and Ryan Tannehill, while the Buccaneers continued to stick by the turnover-prone Jameis Winston despite his career being marred by numerous alleged off-field indiscretions.

Whether Kaepernick would still be good enough to start in the NFL is open for debate given the length of his absence, but the fact he has not even been afforded a chance to serve as a backup over the last 32 months while teams have traded draft capital to bring in quarterbacks who can only dream of his career is a damning indictment of a league Kaepernick gave so much to in an all too brief pro career.

Related items

  • Football Manager 2021: How Cherno Samba, Freddy Adu and other legends of the game fared in real life Football Manager 2021: How Cherno Samba, Freddy Adu and other legends of the game fared in real life

    It's Football Manager 2021 release day, which means partners of fans of the addictive simulation sensation may not see much of their significant others for the foreseeable future.

    A game with roots dating back to the early 90s, Football Manager has become a phenomenon with players enamoured by the challenge of signing wonderkids from South America or leading a team from non-league to Champions League glory.

    Yes, Football Manager has developed a cult following and a legion of devoted followers to a franchise that simply seems to grow year on year.

    Indeed, many footballers have become famous in their own right not necessarily for their performances on the pitch but for their rise to prominence from boy wonder to global superstar in the world of Football Manager.

    So, to help celebrate the full release of the latest instalment, we have taken a look at how some of the most iconic and infamous players of Football Manager fared in the real world…



    Had Cherno Samba managed to replicate the simulated predictions in real life, perhaps we would have been speaking about him in the same breath as Lionel Messi or Cristiano Ronaldo (hey, we said perhaps!). A prodigious 16-year-old on the books at Millwall on the Championship Manager 2001-02 game, Samba was the man to spearhead a plethora of gamers to global domination. Things didn't quite pan out the same in real life as the former England youth international took in spells in Spain, Greece, Finland and Norway before retiring in 2015. Samba scored on his English Football League debut for Plymouth Argyle against Coventry City in August 2006 but failed to net in any of his following 15 league appearances in England.


    Freddy Adu's is a genuine "what if?" story. The teenager was the man to sign on Championship Manager 4 and was tipped for superstardom after making his professional debut as a 14-year-old with DC United in April 2004, scoring his first professional goal later that month. Adu had a trial with Manchester United but unfortunately never lived up to such high billing, with spells at Benfica and Monaco among a host of clubs he turned out for. In October, Adu announced he had signed for third-tier Swedish side Osterlen - his 15th professional club - after a two-year break from the game.


    A player whose talent forced a positional rethink for David Beckham at Manchester United and was enough to displace Ronaldinho from his favoured No.10 position…on his own Championship Manager saves! On the face of it, Kennedy Bakircioglu's stats were solid if unspectacular (18 for technique, though…) but the attacking midfielder – part of a generation of Swedish talent with Zlatan Ibrahimovic and Kim Kallstrom – was unplayable at times in the simulated world. In reality, Bakircioglu failed to impress on trial with the Red Devils and he had a somewhat nomadic career with spells at the likes of Twente, Ajax and Racing Santander on his resume before retiring back in Sweden with Hammarby a couple of years back.


    A man whose name even to this day is revered by fans of the game. A special attacking midfield talent available for a pittance from Derby County, Moukoko was regularly sought out by players. In real life, Milan were apparently interested in the teenager but sadly personal tragedy struck. Moukoko moved to Sweden with his brother as a child but the death of his sibling left him out of love with football at 18. Moukoko would return to Sweden and also had a spell in Finland.


    True disciples of the Football Manager series will know full well that South America is a hotbed of wonderkid talent. Cruzeiro's Kerlon was one such player on the 2005 game and life looked like imitating art when Serie A giants Inter brought the master of the famed 'seal dribble' to Italy. However, Kerlon's trademark trick – where he would flick the ball into the air and run with it bouncing on his head – never got an airing in the famous Nerazzurri jersey. He failed to make an appearance for Inter, and a host of loans – including one to Ajax where game time similarly didn't arrive – were unable to spark his career. Kerlon went on to play in Japan, the United States, Malta and Slovakia in a journeyman career before retiring in 2017.


    One for the real old guard here, Ibrahima Bakayoko's all-round attributes and clinical finishing meant he was a Championship Manager cert in 97-98 – although a tendency for injuries and a high fee (£5million, no less!!) were potential stumbling blocks. However, away from the simulated world, Bakayoko earned the very harsh nickname "Baka-joke-o" during a spell at Everton that returned just four goals in 23 games having signed from Montpellier. He was the first Ivorian to score a Premier League goal, doing so against Southampton in 1998, but the following season he was back in France playing for Marseille and he would represent 13 clubs in total.


    If you played Football Manager in the middle-to-late noughties, then at some point or another you will have signed Anthony Vanden Borre, a wonderkid across several instalments who could be signed for a nominal fee from Anderlecht. Nowadays, of course, Vanden Borre is arguably best known for Chris Kamara's famous "has he?" gaffe on Sky Sports when informed by Jeff Stelling that the defender had been sent off while playing for Portsmouth in a game 'Kammy' was supposed to be watching. A decent career that has included 28 Belgium caps continued when his former team-mate Vincent Kompany took him back to Anderlecht for a third spell after three years without a team, though largely to work with the club's younger players.


    Still a wonderkid on Football Manager in 2009, two years on from being acclaimed as one of the most exciting teenagers in the world by World Soccer. The Mexico talent showed flashes of brilliance when he made the breakthrough at Arsenal, but consistency was lacking. After several loan spells away from the club, Vela finally found a permanent home at the last of those in Real Sociedad, where he spent a further six seasons. In 2018, Vela moved to MLS with Los Angeles FC. He has been involved in 77 goals in just 69 MLS appearances (54 goals, 23 assists).


    Another player who Gunners fans will attest to the fact that his virtual prowess was not matched at the Emirates. His supposedly deadly finishing made him a must-buy on Football Manager 2011 but a move to Arsenal from Auxerre in 2013 brought little joy. In English football, he netted just two goals in 31 appearances in all competitions for Arsenal and Crystal Palace combined, only to score a hat-trick on his first ever start for Charlton Athletic (his third overall). However, these were the only goals he got for the Addicks. He is without a club after being released by Toulouse in July.


    A debut at 16 and a treble with CSKA Moscow before the age of 20, it doesn't take a genius to work out why the statisticians at Football Manager had such high hopes for Akinfeev – one of the all-time simulation greats. A couple of serious injuries and a high-profile error for Russia against South Korea in the 2014 World Cup meant that Akinfeev never quite delivered on the early promise. Indeed, after keeping six clean sheets in his first 10 Champions League appearances, Akinfeev then conceded at least once in each of his following 43 games in the competition. Still, he is a legend at CSKA and has over 100 caps for Russia.

  • Arians calls for better execution from Buccaneers after defeat to Rams Arians calls for better execution from Buccaneers after defeat to Rams

    Bruce Arians said the Tampa Bay Buccaneers just needed to execute better after falling to the Los Angeles Rams on Monday.

    Tom Brady struggled as the Buccaneers slipped to 7-4 following a 27-24 loss at Raymond James Stadium.

    The Buccaneers quarterback was 26 of 48 for 216 yards and two touchdowns, while Jordan Fuller intercepted him twice – including as Brady looked to lead Tampa Bay on a game-tying or winning drive.

    Buccaneers head coach Arians backed offensive coordinator Byron Leftwich and said execution was Tampa Bay's problem.

    "I thought he called a good ballgame, we've just got to execute better," Arians told a news conference.

    "When guys are open, we've got to hit them and we can't misread coverage. We've got to protect a little bit better when we do have guys deep and let him hit that guy instead of have that pressure that costs us an interception.

    "As a collective, everybody's got to play better."

    Brady took the blame for the second interception thrown to Fuller and Arians said the star quarterback had misread the coverage.

    "The first one he got hit, he got hit, it looked like he had Chris [Godwin] going right down the middle and stepped up and just didn't get enough on it with the pressure, and the last one was just a misread of the coverage," Arians said.

    Two of the Buccaneers' four losses this season have come to the team above them in the NFC South, the New Orleans Saints (8-2).

    Of the six teams they have beaten, only two – the Green Bay Packers (7-3) and Las Vegas Raiders (6-4) – have winning records.

    "At times, we look really, really good, and then there are times when we obviously don't," Arians said.

    "I felt very, very comfortable in the two-minute drive until that throw, but we made some plays and obviously we didn't make enough in this ballgame offensively, defensively or special teams to win."

    The Buccaneers face another huge test against the Kansas City Chiefs (9-1) on Sunday.

  • Bad read, throw, decision, everything – Brady rues late error Bad read, throw, decision, everything – Brady rues late error

    Tom Brady lamented the late interception he threw for the Tampa Bay Buccaneers against the Los Angeles Rams, saying it "can't happen".

    Looking to respond to Matt Gay's field goal, Brady was intercepted by Jordan Fuller for the second time as the Buccaneers fell to the Rams 27-24 on Monday.

    Brady struggled throughout at Raymond James Stadium, going 26 of 48 for 216 yards, two touchdowns and two interceptions, while he was sacked once.

    The six-time Super Bowl champion was particularly unhappy with his late throw as he tried to connect with Cameron Brate.

    "Just a bad read and Cam was running up the seam and the last second I saw the safety coming over and just popped it over Cam's head," Brady told a news conference.

    "Just a bad read, bad throw, decision, everything, can't happen."

    The Buccaneers finished with 251 total yards to the Rams' 413, with LA pair Cooper Kupp and Robert Woods becoming the fourth team-mate duo in the past 70 years to have 11-plus receptions and 130-plus receiving yards in the same game, as per NFL Research.

    Brady said the Buccaneers (7-4) needed to improve ahead of Sunday's blockbuster clash against the Kansas City Chiefs.

    "Tonight was very inefficient, did not a very good job there in the second half, defense played great, kept coming up with huge stops, getting us the ball back and offensively we just couldn't make the plays that were necessary to be efficient," he said.

    "We had plenty of chances so gotta get them fixed."

© 2020 SportsMaxTV All Rights Reserved.