Serena caricature 'way over the top' claims regional cartoonist

By September 13, 2018

Regional cartoonist Guy O’Neal has described the controversial caricature of tennis star Serena Williams as having gone ‘way over the top’ and ‘offensive’.

Australia Herald Sun cartoonist Mark Knight has drawn heavy criticism for his caricature of Serena Williams, following her much-publicized spat with an umpire during the US Open final.  The cartoon itself has divided opinion with some believing the cartoonist was well within his right to express himself, others however viewed the depiction as sexist and racist.  Knight has denied being either.  The Barbadian O’Neal did not side with his fellow cartoonist.

 “I had not seen the cartoon until today (Wednesday) but when I saw it the first thing I saw was this huge woman jumping up and down on a tennis racquet and when I looked closely I realized this is Serena and it was awful,” O’Neal told the SportsMax Zone.

“While cartoonists like myself have license to do a caricature. I think sometimes we can caricature to a point where it becomes offensive and I see a lot of offensiveness in this cartoon,” he added.  

“He’s well within his rights to draw what he wants but I think when it gets to a point when it becomes offensive you have to take a step back.  Rather than going to a point where you offend somebody at this.”

Kwesi Mugisa

Kwesi has been a sports journalist with more than 10-years’ experience in the field. First as a Sports Reporter with The Gleaner in the early 2000s before he made the almost natural transition to becoming an editor. Since then he has led the revamp of The Star’s sports offering, making it a more engaging and forward-thinking component of the most popular tabloid newspaper in the Caribbean.

Related items

  • No 'breathtaking tennis' in Djokovic's win against Zverev No 'breathtaking tennis' in Djokovic's win against Zverev

    Novak Djokovic did not think there was any "breathtaking tennis" in his 6-4 6-1 triumph over Alexander Zverev at the ATP Finals.

    The Serbian staved off two break points at 4-4 in a closely contested opening set, but a costly double fault on set point from Zverev gave the world number one the initiative.

    Third seed Zverev only won one more game as he committed numerous unforced errors and Djokovic closed out the match inside 67 minutes, moving to the brink of an eighth appearance in the semi-finals.

    "I don't think it was breathtaking tennis to be honest from both of us but a win is win," said the 14-time grand slam champion in an on-court interview.

    "I thought I played well from midway through the second set, I started to swing through the ball but I haven't served that great.

    "He obviously made a lot of unforced errors that allowed me to win, probably easier than expected. Especially in the second set he wasn't close to his best."

    Djokovic displayed his typically brilliant defence to keep points alive, with his flexibility leading to his interviewer Annabel Croft calling him Mr Bendy.

    With a chuckle, he replied: "Mr Bendy? That's a first!

    "I've been called different names for the flexibility. I'm obviously relying on it a lot ever since I was a boy, starting to play tennis and I was skiing a lot in those days and playing different sports.

    "I was fortunate to be around people who emphasised the importance of stretching for the longevity of the career. It's paying off right now!"

  • Djokovic charges past Zverev to move closer to ATP Finals progression Djokovic charges past Zverev to move closer to ATP Finals progression

    Novak Djokovic moved closer to an eighth appearance in the last four of the ATP Finals with a commanding 6-4 6-1 victory over third seed Alexander Zverev at the O2 Arena in London.

    Five-time champion Djokovic opened his campaign with a straight-sets win over the powerful John Isner and he consolidated his place at the top of Group Guga Kuerten with an unwavering triumph against Zverev.

    The world number one's place in the semi-finals will be secured if Isner overcomes Marin Cilic or the Croatian wins in three sets later on Wednesday.

    Djokovic said before the match he expected Zverev to play at a higher level than their previous meeting – a 6-2 6-1 win that only took an hour and saw the Serbian break four times without facing a break point himself.

    While Zverev did provide a far greater test in the opening set, the 21-year-old was unable to keep his head in the match after falling behind and made copious unforced errors as Djokovic charged on to a commanding victory.

    Neither player gave anything away in the opening stages and it was not until the ninth game that either was able to engineer a break point, Zverev having benefited from a net cord that sent his forehand looping over Djokovic.

    The German was unable to take his two chances to move in front as Djokovic held on, and the top seed was ahead when, on his third set point, the German frustratingly double faulted after his excellent start.

    Although Zverev showed great character to hold on to his first service game in the second set, it proved to be the last one he would win during the match.

    A wayward shot from the German went long and gave Djokovic two break points, before a botched backhand put the 31-year-old 3-1 up.

    Zverev's poor volley at the net enabled Djokovic to take the first of three break points in game six and victory was complete after a long forehand from the world number five.


    Djokovic [1] bt Zverev [3] 6-4 6-1

    Djokovic - 11/13
    Zverev - 20/33

    Djokovic - 1/3
    Zverev - 9/2

    Djokovic - 3/5
    Zverev - 0/2

    Djokovic - 61
    Zverev - 60

    Djokovic - 75/70
    Zverev - 66/35

    Djokovic - 61
    Zverev - 41

  • Radwanska retires from tennis at 29 Radwanska retires from tennis at 29

    Former world number two and 2015 WTA Finals champion Agnieszka Radwanska has retired from tennis at the age of 29.

    Radwanska won 20 WTA titles in her career, including the WTA Finals in Singapore three years ago, and she reached the final of Wimbledon in 2012, becoming the first Polish player to make it that far in a grand slam singles tournament in the Open Era.

    However, having failed to make it past the fourth round of a grand slam since the 2016 Australian Open semi-finals, the current world number 75 has announced her retirement from the sport.

    "After 13 years of playing tennis competitively, I have decided to end my career," Radwanska wrote on Facebook.

    "This was not an easy decision. I am grateful to have so many special memories, including 20 WTA titles, the WTA Championships in Singapore, a Wimbledon final, and so many others.

    "Unfortunately, I am no longer able to train and play the way I used to, and recently my body can't live up to my expectations.

    "Taking into consideration my health and the heavy burdens of professional tennis, I have to concede that I'm not able to push my body to the limits required.

    "I'm hanging the racquet up and say goodbye to the pro tour."

    Radwanska won her first WTA title in 2007 and her last in 2016 and WTA chairman Steve Simon said her impact would be lasting.

    "Agnieszka embodies the qualities that make a true champion, on the court delivering world-class performances and incredible displays of athleticism, and off the court with her poise, professionalism and support for her fellow players," he added.

    "Agnieszka leaves a legacy on the game across the globe and on behalf of the WTA, she will truly be missed."

SportsMax Zone

Latest Tweets

'Taxi' gets his reward for consistent hard work with the Red Bulls. See story here: #RBNY…
With two world titles and a world-age-group record under her belt in 2018, can Briana Williams win the prestigious…
Join the discussion! Zone Blitz: Nicholas has always shown promise but does he have a future with the Windies? …
Follow SportsMax on Twitter
© 2018 SportsMaxTV All Rights Reserved.