Man City ban lifted by CAS: 'Tainted' evidence might have been key to verdict

By Sports Desk July 13, 2020

UEFA's reliance on evidence first uncovered by Football Leaks could have been key to the outcome of Manchester City's Court of Arbitration for Sport appeal, according to a sports law expert.

The Premier League club had a two-year ban from UEFA competitions overturned on Monday, after CAS concluded they did not disguise equity funding as sponsorship contributions.

City were fined €10million – down from €30m – for failing to cooperate with the initial investigation, which saw them found guilty of breaching Financial Fair Play rules by European football's governing body.

However, CAS concluded that the alleged breaches were "not established or time-barred" – the latter element referring to UEFA's own rulebook that states claimed irregularities from more than five years ago are not admissible for punishment.

UEFA's latest investigation into City, who they fined for falling foul of FFP regulations in May 2014, stemmed from a series of reports by Der Spiegel, the German publication that drew on documents obtained by the whistleblower Football Leaks, purportedly showing funds from sponsors linked to the club's Abu Dhabi ownership had been improperly topped up.

Richard Cramer of Front Row Legal, a specialist in sports law, feels UEFA's reliance on those findings is likely to have been seized upon by City's legal team.

"We're waiting for the full verdict, so it's a little bit premature to be critical of UEFA or Manchester City," he told Stats Perform News. "What we do know is that this has been an ongoing matter since 2014.

"I would imagine the thrust of the submissions made by Manchester City, who had probably the finest legal brains in the country representing them, is that [Football Leaks] evidence is regarded as tainted because someone hacked into [City's] IT system."

While Pep Guardiola can call upon the midfield mastery of Kevin De Bruyne on the pitch, Cramer explained City's owners had their own courtroom superstar when it came to taking on UEFA in the form of Lord David Pannick QC.

Lord Pannick led the Supreme Court Article 50 case that Gina Miller brought against the UK government in relation to its Brexit policy and is highly respected in legal circles.

"Manchester City were able – and not every club can do this – to appoint probably the finest legal brains this country has got," Cramer reiterated.

"They brought out the golden boy, which was David Pannick QC.

"David Pannick is a very safe pair of hands, highly eminent and has clearly understood the issues. Him and the team around him have produced a magnificent result."

What that result means for UEFA is not immediately clear.

In a statement after the verdict, the organisation underlined its commitment to the principles of FFP, although further tweaks to a model first introduced in 2009 are to be expected.

While acknowledging the decision will hurt in Nyon, Cramer does not expect any further legal recourse – which in this instance would come with an appeal to the Swiss Federal Tribunal.

"It would have been difficult for Manchester City to take the matter to the Swiss Federal Court," he said. "Similarly, I think it's difficult for UEFA to appeal that decision.

"The only basis upon which either party has got grounds to take this further is if there have been procedural irregularities in the Court of Arbitration for Sport's proceedings, or the decision is perverse or capricious.

"UEFA will be licking their wounds and considering with their lawyers whether there is another avenue, but there's also an element that will probably say 'enough is enough' and to create further uncertainty hanging over the club isn't good.

"I suspect they'll probably throw the towel in and just take it on the chin."

Related items

  • Wolves 0-1 Sevilla: Jimenez penalty miss costly as Ocampos sets up Man Utd semi-final Wolves 0-1 Sevilla: Jimenez penalty miss costly as Ocampos sets up Man Utd semi-final

    Lucas Ocampos punished Raul Jimenez's early penalty miss with a late winner as Sevilla beat Wolves 1-0 in Wednesday's Europa League quarter-final at the MSV-Arena.

    Sevilla have won the competition in its various guises a record five times and will now face Manchester United on Sunday for a place in the final.

    It may have been a different story in Duisburg had Jimenez converted from 12 yards but Yassine Bounou made a save and Ocampos glanced in the only goal two minutes from time.

    Wolves, whose European adventure started 13 months and 17 games ago, had too little time to respond and Sevilla saw things through to advance to another continental semi-final.

  • Shakhtar Donetsk 4-1 Basel: Taison and Marlos star to secure Inter semi-final in Europa League Shakhtar Donetsk 4-1 Basel: Taison and Marlos star to secure Inter semi-final in Europa League

    Shakhtar Donetsk eased past Basel 4-1 on Tuesday to book an intriguing Europa League semi-final against Inter.

    The 2008-09 UEFA Cup winners made light work of their Swiss opponents in Gelsenkirchen after scoring early through Moraes.

    Taison doubled Shakhtar's lead and further goals could and perhaps should have followed long before Alan Patrick's penalty made it three as Basel were dominated in the one-legged last-eight tie.

    Shakhtar, who got a late fourth through Dodo, will surely now back themselves to at least cause Antonio Conte's Inter problems next week, although this routine victory did little to test their readiness.

    Luis Castro's side led after just 100 seconds with the aid of some generous goalkeeping from stand-in Djordje Nikolic.

    Marlos delivered a corner from the right and Nikolic, playing due to Jonas Omlin's injury, lunged hopelessly towards the ball, granting Moraes an open goal when he got there first with the header.

    Afimico Pululu shot agonisingly across the face of goal at the other end, but Shakhtar remained in control and the second soon followed.

    A speedy break from halfway resulted in Marlos controlling on the right corner of the box, taking his time to pick out Taison, whose wayward attempt was deflected high into the net by Fabian Frei.

    Nikolic saved smartly from Moraes and was alert again as Marlos rifled an effort goalwards from 20 yards, before Marcos Antonio swept a stunning strike against the crossbar.

    Basel belatedly enjoyed a better spell just after the hour mark, but a VAR review did not provide Pululu with a penalty and then Arthur Cabral squandered a big opportunity, lifting his finish wide of goal with Andriy Pyatov stranded.

    There would be no fightback as Taison went over in the area and a spot-kick did this time follow, allowing Alan Patrick to calmly beat a scrambling Nikolic.

    There was still time for Dodo to thump in number four following Mateus Tete's well-timed pass on the counter, with Ricky van Wolfswinkel's stoppage-time tap-in from Kemal Ademi's centre the scantest of consolations. 


    What does it mean? Elite European experience tells

    This Shakhtar side are experienced campaigners in continental competition and made the most of the absence of a couple of key men in the Basel XI, with Nikolic and centre-back Jasper van der Werff each struggling.

    The Ukrainians showed their nous throughout a comfortable triumph, pouncing on Basel's errors while making few of their own. Inter should prove a different proposition.

    Marvellous Marlos dazzles

    Shakhtar's best work was channelled through Marlos, who excelled from set-pieces and so often picked the right pass in open play – as evidenced by his assists.

    The second goal in particular came courtesy of the winger's calm in the final third. With Shakhtar players bombing forward, Marlos steadied himself and, when he might have rushed a shot, teed up Taison.

    Nikolic nixes Basel hopes

    Shakhtar were clear favourites coming into this clash, but Basel did not need to look far for inspiration. Quarter-final underdogs Copenhagen had taken Manchester United to extra-time on Monday.

    But where Copenhagen kept things tight and relied on a standout performance from their goalkeeper, Basel's Nikolic quickly erred. The inexperienced 23-year-old was foolishly tempted from his line with less than two minutes on the clock and gave his side a mountain to climb.

    What's next?

    Shakhtar might find next opponents Inter a little less accommodating when they meet in Dusseldorf next Monday.

  • Javi Martinez looking to leave Bayern Munich, Rummenigge confirms Javi Martinez looking to leave Bayern Munich, Rummenigge confirms

    Javi Martinez is looking to leave Bayern Munich after eight years with the German club, chief executive Karl-Heinz Rummenigge has confirmed.

    The 31-year-old midfielder joined Bayern from Athletic Bilbao in 2012 and has won 19 trophies during his time at the Allianz Arena.

    However, Martinez has been restricted to just 10 starts in all competitions in 2019-20 and recently entered the final 12 months of his contract.

    Rummenigge has opened the door for the Spaniard to move on during the close season, with teams in France and former club Athletic rumoured to be interested.

    "We know that he would like to leave the club with a suitable offer," Rummenigge told AZ. 

    "We wouldn't put any obstacles in his way because he was always a good player and a reliable, serious person. We will always try to find a solution that suits the player."

    Rummenigge also reiterated on Wednesday that fellow midfielder Thiago Alcantara, strongly linked with Liverpool, will only be allowed to leave if his valuation is met.

    Bayern are also in talks with versatile defender David Alaba over a new contract, while loanee Philippe Coutinho will return to Barcelona later this month.

© 2020 SportsMaxTV All Rights Reserved.