Zidane returns to Real Madrid: Is the Frenchman right to go back?

By Sports Desk March 12, 2019

They say never go back, but Zinedine Zidane has rarely been someone who pays too much attention to the advice of others. 

Zidane returned to his old role of Real Madrid coach on Monday, just nine months after walking away from the post following their third straight Champions League triumph. 

After a dreadful season that has seen brief and unsuccessful spells for Julen Lopetegui and Santiago Solari, Madrid will be delighted to have Zidane back at the helm. 

So, was he right to return? Here Omnisport's Liam Blackburn and Nicholas McGee debate that question. 

Why Zidane is wrong to go back

By Liam Blackburn

Perhaps Zidane's return could be comprehended if he had unfinished business at the Santiago Bernabeu. Yet after winning three Champions League titles in a row and the 2016-17 LaLiga crown, what is there left for him to achieve with Los Blancos? 

If Zidane wants to be considered an elite manager, he must prove himself away from Madrid, as Jose Mourinho did in multiple countries, and as Pep Guardiola has done since leaving Barcelona. There were murmurs he could be next in line at Juventus if Massimiliano Allegri moved on at the end of the season - the prospect of ending their long wait for Champions League glory would surely have been a more appealing challenge to Zidane. 

Yet instead he has opted for the 'comforts' of Madrid, for a job that seemingly left him jaded just under a year ago. Perhaps he has returned because he has been promised a greater say in transfer dealings – reportedly a bone of contention for Zidane in his first stint - but how much control is president Florentino Perez really willing to cede on that front? 

Sequels are rarely as good as the originals, and Zidane is returning to a Cristiano Ronaldo-less team desperately in need of a rebuild. He won the Champions League every single year he was in charge first time around, how can he possibly live up to those heights again?


Why Zidane is right to go back

By Nicholas McGee

Zidane's legacy at Madrid is already secured. With a hat-trick of Champions League titles under his belt, he will forever be seen as a club legend regardless of what happens in his second spell. 

However, what Zidane will have been disappointed by is how quickly a team that looked so formidable has suddenly crumbled without him. 

He had, by all accounts, warned the club that a tumble down to earth was likely if his demands over transfers were ignored. Madrid have paid the price for failing to heed his words this season, their squad looking unfit for the demands of trying to win on three fronts. 

Part of leaving a legacy is putting something in place that will last, that can carry on after you have gone. For Zidane to return, he will likely have received assurances that Madrid will strengthen. With those in place, and the emergence of Vinicius Junior, Sergio Reguilon and Marcos Llorente this season, Zidane should have much better resources to rebuild a team that can sustain success even after his second stint ends. 

Refreshed after a ninth-month break from the rigours of coaching at the highest level, that is a strong enough reason for Zidane to return to add to his legend by developing a unit that can enjoy long-term dominance in all competitions.

Related items

  • The Australia ball-tampering scandal one year on: Have the batsmen filled the Smith-Warner void? The Australia ball-tampering scandal one year on: Have the batsmen filled the Smith-Warner void?

    Australia have played 43 games across all formats in the time Steve Smith and David Warner have been banned - and the statistics suggest the two should have no problem walking back into the XI for the upcoming Ashes.

    Ex-captain Smith and former vice-captain Warner are available to be selected for their country again from this week when the 12-month bans for their roles in the Cape Town ball-tampering scandal come to an end.

    Here, with the help of Opta, we take a look at how Australia's batsmen have fared across all three formats over the past year without the duo.

     

    TESTS (P9 W3 D2 L4)

    The first Test without Smith, Warner and Cameron Bancroft, who was given a nine-month ban for his part in the saga, ended in a 492-run loss to South Africa as the Proteas wrapped up a 3-1 series success.

    Matthew Renshaw was one of those drafted in for that final match in Johannesburg, but having scored a cumulative 13 across two innings, he has not appeared in a Test since. 

    Peter Handscomb initially filled Smith's spot at four and averaged fewer than 19 across seven innings, though Joe Burns was one of the success stories, the opener's 180 against Sri Lanka last month helping him to an average of 50 over the past year.

    Travis Head (51) had a better average than Burns in that time, but openers Aaron Finch (27.8) and Marcus Harris (32.7) were unable to replicate Warner (48.2), particularly when they struggled in a 2-1 home series loss to India.

    Having made his Test debut in October, Marnus Labuschagne batted at four in the recent two-match series with Sri Lanka, yet his average of 26.3 pales in comparison with Smith's 61.4.

     

    ODIS (P18 W7 L11)

    With a World Cup on English soil looming on the horizon later in 2019, Australia's 50-over fortunes were looking grim as little as three weeks ago.

    A five-match series in India began with defeats in the opening two matches, meaning the world champions had lost 11 of 13 ODIs since the Newlands scandal.

    But a stunning comeback sealed a 3-2 win over Virat Kohli's men, and Australia have continued that momentum in the UAE, where successive Finch hundreds mean the tourists lead Pakistan 2-0 in a best-of-five contest.

    Those centuries have lifted Finch's ODI average across the past year to 39.4, while the likes of Usman Khawaja (60.9), Shaun Marsh (59.3) and Handscomb (52.1) have all benefitted from opportunities they may not otherwise have had.

    Two months out from the start of the World Cup, the holders appear to be finding form at just the right time, and the returns of Smith and Warner will leave head coach Justin Langer nursing a welcome selection headache.

     

    TWENTY20S (P16 W7 L8 NR1)

    Smith's ban had little effect on his nation's T20 form - the 29-year-old having not featured in that format since March 2016 - yet Warner left a bigger void to fill having scored more than any other Australian in the shortest format.

    Despite that, four leading batsmen averaged more than Warner's 26.7 over the previous 12 months.

    Finch amassed 465 runs, though that total comes with the caveat that 324 of those were accrued in his first three innings. In his past 13 T20 knocks for Australia, Finch has averaged only 10.8.

    All-rounder Glenn Maxwell (averaging 34), D'Arcy Short (28.3) and Head (27.3) were the others to shine in Warner and Smith's absences.

  • Leading tight end and Super Bowl star – the numbers behind Gronkowski's greatness Leading tight end and Super Bowl star – the numbers behind Gronkowski's greatness

    Rob Gronkowski will not be back in a New England Patriots uniform in 2019.

    The 29-year-old tight end announced his retirement on Instagram on Sunday. He spent all nine of his NFL seasons in New England.

    "It's time to move forward and move forward with a big smile on my face knowing that the New England Patriots organisation, Pats nation and all my fans will truly be a big part of my heart for the rest of my life," Gronkowski wrote.

    "It was truly an incredible honour to play for such a great, established organisation.”

    Patriots coach Bill Belichick praised Gronkowski later in the day.

    "It was a pleasure and a privilege to coach Rob Gronkowski the past nine years," Belichick said in a statement. "From his rookie year until his final season and through countless times in between, Rob was a major reason why we won games and championships.

    "Rob's impact on our team and organisation was felt in many ways … Rob will leave an indelible mark on the Patriots organisation and the game as among the best, most complete players at his position to ever play."

    Gronkowski, who struggled with injuries throughout his career, won three Super Bowls and made five Pro Bowls during his time with New England.

    Here are five facts about the tight end’s stellar career, thanks to Opta.

    – The tight end tallied four seasons with 1,000 or more receiving yards. That is tied for the most ever by a player at his position.

    – The former Arizona star leads all tight ends in postseason catches (81), receiving yards (1,163) and receiving scores (12). Jerry Rice is the only player who has caught more touchdowns in the playoffs.

    – Gronkowski and Rice are the only two pass catchers in history to register 20 or more receptions, 200 or more receiving yards and three or more touchdowns in the Super Bowl.

    – In 2011, Gronkowski pulled in 17 touchdowns, the most ever by a tight end. Only four players have ever had more receiving scores in a single season.

    – Since he entered the NFL in 2010, Gronkowski has registered seven games with multiple touchdowns and 100 or more receiving yards. Only four wideouts have recorded more: Antonio Brown, Jordy Nelson, Calvin Johnson and Julio Jones.

  • France winger Coman ruled out of Iceland clash France winger Coman ruled out of Iceland clash

    Kingsley Coman has been ruled out of France's Euro 2020 qualifier against Iceland due to back pain, Didier Deschamps has confirmed.

    Bayern Munich winger Coman will return to his club as he is not fit to take part in Monday's Group E game at the Stade de France.

    Coman had been set to start the opening match of France's qualifying campaign against Moldova but was injured in the warm-up.

    The 22-year-old's career has been regularly affected by injury and he missed three months of action for Bayern after damaging ankle ligaments on the first weekend of the Bundesliga season.

    Deschamps told a news conference no replacement would be called up for Coman, with Blaise Matuidi having taken his place in the side for a 4-1 win in Moldova.

    World champions France are already without left-back Lucas Digne after he returned to Everton having sustained a thigh injury.

© 2018 SportsMaxTV All Rights Reserved.