Match-turning Stokes six 'a clear mistake' from Cricket World Cup final umpires

By Sports Desk July 15, 2019

England should have been awarded five runs, not six, when Ben Stokes inadvertently deflected a throw to the boundary in Sunday's epic Cricket World Cup final.

An apologetic Stokes earned six runs when he accidently nudged the ball for four as he lunged to complete a second run in the final over of England's innings, helping the hosts to tie the match with New Zealand and reach a Super Over.

England subsequently won due to their superior boundary count, but Simon Taufel says the Lord's umpires made "a clear mistake".

The MCC laws state additional runs to the boundary can only be awarded if the two batsmen have crossed at the time of the throw.

Stokes and team-mate Adil Rashid had completed one run but had not crossed a second time when Martin Guptill launched the ball back towards the wicket, meaning five runs should have been given.

Rashid would also have been on strike rather than star man Stokes.

Five-time ICC Umpire of the Year Taufel, part of the MCC laws sub-committee, acknowledged the error but had sympathy for on-field officials Kumar Dharmasena and Marais Erasmus.

"[England] should have been awarded five runs, not six," Taufel told FOX Sports. "It's a clear mistake - it's an error of judgment.

"In the heat of what was going on, they thought there was a good chance the batsmen had crossed at the instant of the throw. Obviously TV replays showed otherwise.

"The difficulty you have here is you've got to watch batsmen completing runs, then change focus and watch for the ball being picked up, and watch for the release [of the throw].

"You also have to watch where the batsmen are at that exact moment.

"[But] it's unfair on England, New Zealand and the umpires involved to say it decided the outcome."

Related items

  • Ashes 2019: Perfect team-mate Stokes has heart of a lion - Broad Ashes 2019: Perfect team-mate Stokes has heart of a lion - Broad

    Ben Stokes has the heart of a lion and is the perfect team-mate says Stuart Broad, who admitted he thought the Ashes were over for England.

    Stokes made a brilliant unbeaten 135 as England remarkably recovered from 286-9 to chase down 359 and beat Australia by one wicket at Headingley on Sunday, leaving the series level at 1-1 with two Tests to play.

    The England all-rounder, who starred in the World Cup final, also took four wickets in the match as he followed his unbeaten 115 at Lord's with another world-class performance in Leeds.

    Jack Leach provided vital support with one not out but Stokes went into one-day mode, hitting eight sixes in a blistering innings to secure one of cricket's most dramatic victories.

    "It was one of those 'I was there' moments," Broad said to Sky Sports. "It was absolutely spectacular. I don't think anyone in this ground will see a better innings. It had everything. He struck the ball beautifully.

    "The bloke has got the heart of a lion. Everything he does is for the team. He is the perfect team-mate. He didn't celebrate his fifty; he didn't celebrate his hundred. He deserves everything that comes his way because he's an incredible cricketer and an even better bloke.

    "The emotions of that last hour were outrageous. Cricketers don't go through that in careers - so for some of these World Cup players to go through that twice in six weeks is outrageous.

    "The belief has always been there in this game. But nine down, one ball finishes the Ashes series. Of course I thought the Ashes were over."

    England won the toss and put Australia in, failing to capitalise on reducing the tourists to 25-2, then making a pitiful 67 all out in response to give Tim Paine's side a huge advantage.

    But after Joe Root's 77 built a platform for England's record chase, Stokes spectacularly completed the job and Broad feels his team are now favourites.

    "On day one we should have bowled Australia out for 120 to be honest," Broad added. "I apologised to the guys after that.

    "67 all out is inexcusable, we didn't show any responsibility, we didn't communicate well. It was really poor.

    "Then we could have bowled them out for 150 again in the second innings. It's been a sloppy game for us but one man's heroics has bailed us out and now we all have to step it up.

    "Headingley has seen some special Tests over the years, the support was incredible. 1-1 didn't look possible two hours ago and now I am backing us to go on and win it."

    Old Trafford hosts the fourth Test, which gets under way on September 4.

  • Ashes 2019: Stokes knock as good as anything I've seen in Tests - Ponting Ashes 2019: Stokes knock as good as anything I've seen in Tests - Ponting

    Former Australia captain Ricky Ponting said Ben Stokes' remarkable innings was as good as anything he has seen in Test cricket, as England levelled the Ashes in sensational circumstances.

    England were 286-9 in pursuit of 359 at Headingley and staring down the barrel of a 2-0 deficit that would have seen Australia retain the urn with two matches to spare.

    But Stokes played one of the great Test innings and his unbeaten 135 steered England to the unlikeliest of one-wicket victories in front a pumped-up crowd on Sunday.

    Ponting was effusive in his praise when assessing Stokes' performance on Sky Sports and stated the all-rounder did not get one decision wrong.

    "I'm not sure I've seen anything better than that on a Test ground, to be honest," he said. 

    "He scored two off 64 balls, but we always felt that if he was there then England were going to be in with a chance to win.

    "Deep down he knew that as well. He wanted to be the man to be there at the end regardless of how long it took.

    "Some of that hitting today - when it was 73 to win and nine down - he had to go there and then he pulled it off. That was brilliant.

    "Decision-making plays such a big part in any innings that you play. He got every decision right today under extreme pressure - the way that he hit the boundaries and maintained the strike."

    The fourth Test begins at Old Trafford on September 4, with the series now locked at 1-1.

  • Ashes 2019: England must take inspiration from saviour Stokes - Root Ashes 2019: England must take inspiration from saviour Stokes - Root

    Joe Root says Ben Stokes' heroics against Australia must act as a marker for his team-mates in the remainder of the Ashes.

    England levelled the 2019 series at 1-1 with a dramatic one-wicket win at Headingley on Sunday that owed much to a masterful 135 not out from all-rounder Stokes.

    Captain Root had helped set the platform for the victory with 77 but, when Jos Buttler was run out following a mix-up with Stokes, England's hopes of keeping the series alive looked slim.

    Australia were on the brink of retaining the Ashes when Stuart Broad fell to James Pattinson but last man Jack Leach made a gritty one not out as Stokes went into one-day mode to see England to their target of 359.

    Stokes was also the star when England lifted the Cricket World Cup earlier this year at Lord's and Root wants England to take inspiration from his latest contribution with two Tests still to play.

    "We said at the start of the day we just had to believe," Root said at the post-match presentation. 

    "We have witnessed some freakish things this summer during the World Cup and I didn't think we would see something so similar happen during the Ashes.

    "It was an incredible game of cricket, an incredible atmosphere, Test cricket is alive and kicking, as is this Ashes series. It is fabulous to be able to stand here, be 1-1 all in this series and take all of this in.

    "To try and sum up Stokes' innings in words is impossible. He has got previous and he has got that in the bank, he had to call upon all that but to stay as calm and collected as he did in the moment it took a great amount of skill, courage and belief in his own ability. It is a fabulous marker for everyone.

    "I am still trying to get my head around everything, it was just amazing. When you are on the right end of these sorts of results it carries a lot of weight. Hopefully it can make a big difference.

    "Ben deserves all the plaudits and adulation that he gets given."

    England and Australia resume the series at Old Trafford for the penultimate Test of the series, with the action starting on September 4.

© 2018 SportsMaxTV All Rights Reserved.