"I will not be tendering apology" to JADCO - Dr Emir Crowne

By October 04, 2019

Noted sports attorney Dr. Emir Crowne will not be apologizing to the Jamaica Anti-Doping Commission (JADCO) for comments he made about the commission in the days leading up to the anti-doping hearing involving Jamaican sprinter Briana Williams.

Dr Crowne said he was well within the law with his comments and that the threat of legal action from JADCO was an effort to distract and confuse him.

In the days leading up the hearing, Dr Crowne had expressed his concerns about information leaked to the media about Williams’ ‘A’ and ‘B’ samples before him, or the athlete he represented, had received that information.

 In an article published in the Jamaica Observer on Wednesday, August 28, Dr Crowne articulated those concerns saying, “There was a need for public scrutiny as to how JADCO maintains its results process.”

In response, attorneys representing JADCO said Dr Crowne made “a clear inference or implication that JADCO leaked the results of the ‘A’ and ‘B’ samples of Briana Williams…”

In a letter dated September 3, 2019, JADCO demanded an apology and threatened the initiation of legal action, should Dr Crowne fail to issue a former apology by September 6?

A month later, on October 3, JADCO’s attorneys, in a letter to Dr Crowne, extended the deadline to Friday, October 4.

However, in a strongly worded reply on Friday, Dr Crowne declared that he has no intention of apologizing.

“Putting aside the technicalities and theatrics that have unfortunately dominated this matter, I will not be tendering an apology,” Dr Crowne said.

In his letter, the attorney, who has represented several Jamaican athletes before disciplinary panels, outlined that he found the initial letter sent by JADCO’s attorneys “rather unsavoury and curiously timed given my representation of an athlete before the Independent Anti-Doping Disciplinary Panel, wherein JADCO appeared as the complainant and the athlete appeared as the respondent.

“Put simply, it was a collateral attack. It was designed to distract and confuse; to no avail, unfortunately.”

He explained in the letter that replied to one of JADCO’s attorneys on September 11 requesting that JADCO stay their hand until October 2. He argued that since the hearing dates for Briana Williams had only recently been set, he would need the time to provide a “fulsome response.”

The attorney, Dr Crowne indicated, replied saying “We will revert to you after discussing your email with our client.”

Dr Crowne said no one reverted to him.

In direct reference to his comments published in the Jamaica Observer, Dr Crowne said every defence at law is available to him in the matter.

Citing absolute privilege Dr Crowne said the comments were made in the course of proceedings against the athlete and were privileged absolutely. The comments were made on an occasion where the public had a right to know how a public body – like JADCO – was operating and are protected by qualified privilege.

He also asserts that the comments were fair comment as they were made honestly and sincerely and there was no malice, “merely a genuine concern for the manner in which JADCO may have handled the matter.”

Dr Crowne also insists that there is truth to the comments made and that JADCO was indirectly forcing him to disclose the “journalists in question who may have a source within JADCO and he will not, under any circumstance, be used to breach source privilege.

The matter has reportedly reached the desk of Jamaican sports minister Olivia Grange.

Leighton Levy

Leighton Levy is a journalist with 28 years’ experience covering crime, entertainment, and sports. He joined the staff at SportsMax.TV as a content editor two years ago and is enjoying the experience of developing sports content and new ideas. At SportsMax.tv he is pursuing his true passion - sports.

Related items

  • Cheslin came through so much – Van Niekerk reflects on Springboks' 'amazing' Rugby World Cup triumph Cheslin came through so much – Van Niekerk reflects on Springboks' 'amazing' Rugby World Cup triumph

    Wayde van Niekerk says it was "an amazing inspiration" to see South Africa win the Rugby World Cup – especially as the team contained friends and family.

    The Springboks triumphed 32-12 over England in the final in Yokohama on November 2 last year to become world champions for the third time.

    Olympic 400-metre champion and world-record holder Van Niekerk says the players deserve all the accolades and sponsorship bonuses they have received for their momentous success.

    "It's been an amazing inspiration for not just myself but the entire country, and yet another spark for myself as a South African to want to achieve great things," he told Stats Perform.

    "I'm quite close friends with a few players and it's great to see how their lives have changed and the blessings and the sponsors and so on that are coming their way. It's amazing, it's well deserved and it's great."

    Van Niekerk is friends with several key South Africa players, including captain Siya Kolisi, and he is a cousin of Cheslin Kolbe.

    Kolbe battled back from injury in time to play against England and went on to score the final try of the match, capping a terrific 2019 that saw him nominated alongside eventual winner Pieter-Steph du Toit for World Rugby's Player of the Year award.

    Van Niekerk recalled: "Thinking back to Cheslin's final try: he's come through so much, moving to France, thinking that he wouldn't make the SA team, and just wanting to go and enjoy his rugby and then getting selected for the World Cup.

    "The final try was amazing but let's be honest, his entire tournament, I feel like he was one of the players of the tournament and one of the highlights of the Rugby World Cup.

    "I think it's such a blessing and such an amazing blessing to be associated with such great people, like Siya and Cheslin, it's lovely to be associated with them and draw off of them and use them as inspiration for myself, coming back from injury and wanting to do great things for my country the way they did."

  • Pearson Jordan was third Barbadian athlete to die in the past month - Barbados Athletics Pearson Jordan was third Barbadian athlete to die in the past month - Barbados Athletics

    When Barbadian OIympian Pearson Jordan died last Saturday, March 28, from COVID-19, he was one of three sportsmen from that country to have died in the past month.

  • COVID-19 set to change Athletics for the next five years - Boldon COVID-19 set to change Athletics for the next five years - Boldon

    The impact of the Tokyo 2020 postponement, as well as others means track and field athletes can look forward to a tough four years to come, so says former Trinidad & Tobago sprinter and Olympic medallist Ato Boldon.

    According to Boldon, the movement of the Olympics to the Summer of 2021 is likely to push the World Championships to 2022, sparking a domino effect on other major games.

    “It means that we may be in for four championship years in a row. We know that the summer Olympics are going to be in 2021. I think they are going to push the World Championships over to 2022 which means that it then conflicts with the Commonwealth Games and the World Cup, and then we get back on stream with the regular schedule of 2023 World Championships and 2024 Olympics in Paris,” said Boldon.

    These movements, Boldon believes, won’t reset the athletic calendar for another five years, but sees no real alternative to the unprecedented action of putting an Olympics in an odd year.

    Boldon has an interest in what the next few years of athletics holds as the coach of rising star, Briana Williams.

    Williams was set to contest for a place in her first Olympics and in a recent SportsMax.tv interview, Boldon said the delay was good for his athlete, who would have a year to get stronger.

© 2020 SportsMaxTV All Rights Reserved.