"I will not be tendering apology" to JADCO - Dr Emir Crowne

By October 04, 2019

Noted sports attorney Dr. Emir Crowne will not be apologizing to the Jamaica Anti-Doping Commission (JADCO) for comments he made about the commission in the days leading up to the anti-doping hearing involving Jamaican sprinter Briana Williams.

Dr Crowne said he was well within the law with his comments and that the threat of legal action from JADCO was an effort to distract and confuse him.

In the days leading up the hearing, Dr Crowne had expressed his concerns about information leaked to the media about Williams’ ‘A’ and ‘B’ samples before him, or the athlete he represented, had received that information.

 In an article published in the Jamaica Observer on Wednesday, August 28, Dr Crowne articulated those concerns saying, “There was a need for public scrutiny as to how JADCO maintains its results process.”

In response, attorneys representing JADCO said Dr Crowne made “a clear inference or implication that JADCO leaked the results of the ‘A’ and ‘B’ samples of Briana Williams…”

In a letter dated September 3, 2019, JADCO demanded an apology and threatened the initiation of legal action, should Dr Crowne fail to issue a former apology by September 6?

A month later, on October 3, JADCO’s attorneys, in a letter to Dr Crowne, extended the deadline to Friday, October 4.

However, in a strongly worded reply on Friday, Dr Crowne declared that he has no intention of apologizing.

“Putting aside the technicalities and theatrics that have unfortunately dominated this matter, I will not be tendering an apology,” Dr Crowne said.

In his letter, the attorney, who has represented several Jamaican athletes before disciplinary panels, outlined that he found the initial letter sent by JADCO’s attorneys “rather unsavoury and curiously timed given my representation of an athlete before the Independent Anti-Doping Disciplinary Panel, wherein JADCO appeared as the complainant and the athlete appeared as the respondent.

“Put simply, it was a collateral attack. It was designed to distract and confuse; to no avail, unfortunately.”

He explained in the letter that replied to one of JADCO’s attorneys on September 11 requesting that JADCO stay their hand until October 2. He argued that since the hearing dates for Briana Williams had only recently been set, he would need the time to provide a “fulsome response.”

The attorney, Dr Crowne indicated, replied saying “We will revert to you after discussing your email with our client.”

Dr Crowne said no one reverted to him.

In direct reference to his comments published in the Jamaica Observer, Dr Crowne said every defence at law is available to him in the matter.

Citing absolute privilege Dr Crowne said the comments were made in the course of proceedings against the athlete and were privileged absolutely. The comments were made on an occasion where the public had a right to know how a public body – like JADCO – was operating and are protected by qualified privilege.

He also asserts that the comments were fair comment as they were made honestly and sincerely and there was no malice, “merely a genuine concern for the manner in which JADCO may have handled the matter.”

Dr Crowne also insists that there is truth to the comments made and that JADCO was indirectly forcing him to disclose the “journalists in question who may have a source within JADCO and he will not, under any circumstance, be used to breach source privilege.

The matter has reportedly reached the desk of Jamaican sports minister Olivia Grange.

Leighton Levy

Leighton Levy is a journalist with 28 years’ experience covering crime, entertainment, and sports. He joined the staff at SportsMax.TV as a content editor two years ago and is enjoying the experience of developing sports content and new ideas. At SportsMax.tv he is pursuing his true passion - sports.

Related items

  • IAAF president dubs post-Bolt World Champs the best in history IAAF president dubs post-Bolt World Champs the best in history

    IAAF President Sebastian Coe has described the IAAF World Athletics Championships Doha 2019 as the best in history in terms of the quality and depth of performances produced by the athletes of more than 200 nations.

    Speaking after the final evening session last Sunday, Coe noted that six championship records had been set, 43 countries had won medals, and athletes from 68 different nations had achieved at least one top-eight placing. There have been 21 area records – double the number from 2017 – and 86 national records have been broken, underlining the global reach of the sport.

    “For those who follow our sport closely, you will know that we rank our championships on the performances of the athletes,” Coe said. “It is how we, the athletes and the coaches measure our success.

    “The world’s athletes have put on the best show in the history of the IAAF World Athletics Championships, according to the competition performance rankings which are used as an objective measure of the quality of international competition.

    “These performances are incredible but credit must also go to the facilities and conditions provided by the host country. Doha has created conditions on the field of play and in the warm up that are unsurpassed.

    “We are proud of the fact we reach more countries than any other sport,” added Coe. “Just look at the breadth and depth – 43 countries on the medals table and 86 national records set. We want our athletes to experience different cultures and different conditions. It’s what makes our sport so accessible.”

    Dahlan Al Hamad, Vice President of the local organising committee, was delighted to see Qatar’s dreams become reality.

    “Our dream started in 1997 when we organised the first meeting in this stadium,” he said. “After that, we kept hosting many meets until 2000 when we organised the Grand Prix Final. We continued our journey in 2010 when we organised the World Indoor Championships in the nearby Aspire Dome. We also organised the Diamond League meeting here and it was really good.

    “We are thrilled we have been able to expand. There are generations here who are hungry to have this kind of sporting event here. Qatar is a nation of more than 100 communities. They have been able to celebrate their athletes from all around the world.”

     

    Top ranked World Championships

    Based on the IAAF competition performance rankings, used to rank the quality of competitions, the IAAF World Athletics Championships Doha 2019 tops the list of all World Championships to date.

     

    Taking the best five results and athletes from the best 24 events, the top five editions are:

     

    1. 2019, Doha – 195,869
    2. 2015, Beijing – 194,547
    3. 2017, London – 193,426
    4. 2013, Moscow – 192,664
    5. 2009, Berlin – 191,168

     

    Based on the average scores of all track and field results, the top five editions are:

     

    1. 2019, Doha – 1024.75
    2. 2017, London – 1012.84
    3. 1999, Seville – 1007.98
    4. 2015, Beijing – 1004.78
    5. 2009, Berlin – 1004.55

     

    There have been many outstanding performances over the 10 days of competition with unprecedented depth in many of the finals. Based on the IAAF scoring tables, the top five men’s and women’s performances are:

     

    MEN

    22.91m Joe Kovacs (USA) shot put – 1295pts

    22.90m Tom Walsh (NZL) shot put – 1294pts

    22.90m Ryan Crouser (USA) shot put – 1294pts

    9.76 Christian Coleman (USA) 100m – 1291pts

    43.48 Steven Gardiner (BAH) 400m – 1289pts

     

    WOMEN

    7.30m Malaika Mihambo (GER) long jump – 1288pts

    48.14 Salwa Eid Naser (BRN) 400m – 1281pts

    48.37 Shaunae Miller-Uibo (BAH) 400m – 1272pts

    3:51.95 Sifan Hassan (NED) 1500m – 1271pts

    6981 Katarina Johnson-Thompson (GBR) heptathlon – 1269pts

     

    The championships have not just been about record-breaking performances, though. This edition will also be remembered for its close finishes, surprise winners, moments of fair play, and the arrival of the next generation of athletics stars.

    USA’s 200m winner Noah Lyles and Germany’s decathlon victor Niklas Kaul became the youngest ever world champions in their respective events. Ukraine’s Yaroslava Mahuchikh twice broke the world U20 record on her way to the silver medal in the high jump. She was one of several athletes born in or after the year 2000 who earned medals, along with Ethiopian duo Selemon Barega and Lemecha Girma and Bahrain’s Musa Isah.

    The innovations – including light shows, new camera angles and increased engagement with athletes – have helped the sport reach a younger audience around the world.

  • Nike to close Oregon Project after Salazar ban Nike to close Oregon Project after Salazar ban

    Nike has decided to close down the Oregon Project less than a fortnight after coach Alberto Salazar was banned from athletics for four years.

    The United States Anti-Doping Agency sanctioned Salazar, former coach of long-distance great Mo Farah, at the start of this month after he was found guilty of multiple anti-doping violations.

    Nike on Friday confirmed it will continue to back Salazar with his appeal, but the Oregon Project will be brought to an end.

    A company spokesperson said: "Nike has always tried to put the athlete and their needs at the front of all of our decisions.

    "While the panel found there was no orchestrated doping, no finding that performance enhancing drugs have ever been used on Oregon Project athletes and went out of its way to note Alberto's desire to follow all rules, ultimately Alberto can no longer coach while the appeal is pending.

    "This situation including uninformed innuendo and unsubstantiated assertions has become an unfair burden for current OP athletes. That is exactly counter to the purpose of the team.

    "We have therefore made the decision to wind down the Oregon Project to allow the athletes to focus on their training and competition needs.

    "We will help all of our athletes in this transition as they choose the coaching set-up that is right for them. We will continue to support Alberto in his appeal."

    Japanese athlete Suguru Osako, who joined the Oregon Project four years ago, expressed his disappointment over the decision.

    He tweeted: "I am sad that the dear team that made me stronger will be gone. But I will keep exploring myself and I will continue being myself.

    "As Nike has expressed their commitment to continuing support as they have, my activities will not be disrupted at all."

  • Is Shelly-Ann Fraser-Pryce the greatest female track athlete of all time? Is Shelly-Ann Fraser-Pryce the greatest female track athlete of all time?

    In looking back at what they describe as an amazing IAAF World Championships of Athletics, The Commentators have come up on a question. Is Shelly-Ann Fraser-Pryce, after adding two gold medals to her World Championships tally, the greatest female track athlete of all time?

© 2018 SportsMaxTV All Rights Reserved.